

Committed: The Ties that Bond
with Angella Dykstra
I'm a mom of three, a professional accountant, and an amateur photographer and writer. I am not a marriage expert. But my husband and I take "Til death do us part" seriously, and here I'll be sharing how we keep our marriage strong while we both do that insane work-life juggle.
Check out my Work It, Mom! profile and my blog, Dutch Blitz.
|
My husband and I will be celebrating our tenth (!) wedding anniversary in May. Our kids are old enough to understand the calendar (Well, the oldest is - his brother lives in a constant state of “I don’t know” and his sister is only three) which means that the topic of our wedding has been brought up as of late. This past weekend we hauled out our wedding albums, much to the delight of our little monsters monkeys.
Looking through the photos got me thinking about that whole day and how once it was over and we were on our honeymoon, my husband and I both agreed that if we were to go back in time and do it again, we would have eloped.
It’s not that the day was bad or anything. It was fine and good and I ended up married to the love of my life when all was said and done. It just wasn’t amazing.
We paid for our own wedding and refused to go into debt to do so, which meant that we put a lot of hours into preparing things ourselves and cut corners where we could. We made centerpieces but there were no decorations. We had our reception in the gymnasium at our (large) church which did not make for a magical atmosphere…nor did it allow for wine and/or dancing. We had dinner, made the rounds to say hi to everyone and then the party was over. Well, another party was about to begin but I’ll spare you the details.
When we were laying on the beach in Mexico we wished that instead of hosting a dinner for 125 people, some of whom we barely knew (But were ordered to invite), we had just gotten married at the resort we were staying at. Breathtaking location, beautiful facilities, tropical atmosphere. Anyone that wanted to join us would be welcome to, but that would be up to them. Then, upon arriving home we would have a backyard barbecue with our close friends and family.
To us, that sounds pretty close to perfect.
What are your thoughts? Is a big wedding the way to go or does a trip to Mexico (Or Vegas!) sound like a better option?
Subscribe to blog via RSS






My husband and I eloped at an old hotel in the French Quarter in New Orleans. The day of our wedding, we walked up the street to a flower shop and the nice owner made me a bouquet of various flowers. The day that we were leaving to come home, we mailed an wedding announcement/invitation for everyone to join us at our home to celebrate a couple of weeks later. It’s been 10 years and we’ve never regretted it. It’s a great story and we had a lot of fun at our party.
Sharon | March 23rd, 2010 at 8:45 am
Like you, we set a tight budget and ended up doing so. much. work. to cut corners. During the wedding itself little things came back to bite us that we simply didn’t know to plan for. Things that could have been avoided with a wedding planner and, well, more cash. Also, we couldn’t afford a photographer, which is my one big regret, looking back.
I like the idea of a big wedding, but big weddings are expensive. If I could do the whole thing over again with double (at least) the cash, I would. If I had the thing to do all over again with the same budget - I would have just gone somewhere and had a backyard BBQ for family when we got back.
Danica | March 23rd, 2010 at 9:07 am
We had a hybrid wedding. We got married in Salt Spring Island, BC one year after seriously considering eloping (we tried to get married there and then, but SSI didn’t have the offices we needed to get the marriage certificate and we were leaving the next day). My generous parents, who used to live in the Seattle area thought the destination idea was great and offered to pay to fly out immediate family for a vacation wedding. A total of 7 of us flew to Seattle for a couple of days and saw where my parents lived, then drove up to Vancouver then eventually ferried over to SSI. My parents rented a large farm house for the week, we got married on a Monday in a garden and Mark and I spent 3 days at a great little resort away from the family while they vacationed (we paid for the “honeymoon” part of our trip). We rejoined them for 2 nights, drove back to Seattle and flew home to Ohio.
A month later, as part of the agreement with my parents Mark and I hosted a reception which we paid for (with a little help from dad on the booze because all we could afford was beer and wine - he wanted top shelf so he paid the difference). It was a cocktail reception with hors d’Ĺ“uvres for about 100 so the price wasn’t too bad. And we had fun, even if there were people we were forced to invite. Plus, I wore my wedding dress again!
Anyway, I wouldn’t do anything different. I kept thinking during the recpetion that I was SO GLAD I didn’t have to do the hostess thing right after our wedding. We were able to really enjoy the party and cut loose. And I realized that while I was totally chill about planning the actaul wedding 3000 miles away, I became a crazy bridzilla over the reception details. Have the 2 be a month apart helped keep the wedding day calm and enjoyable.
Plus we now have “our place” to visit every few years on our anniversary. We’ve been back to Salt Spring 3x and we had hoped to go back this summer to celebrate our 10th but with the new baby arriving I think we are going to have to push it back a year (sob!!)
kakaty | March 23rd, 2010 at 9:15 am
I’m not married, but I’ve always thought that if I ever do decide to someday, I want a small ceremony with just my family on a beach somewhere warm, and then a party for everyone later on when we’re back. It seems so much less complicated and stressful to do it that way. But who knows - I could change my mind (I’m notorious for doing that), or never end up getting married.
Sharon | March 23rd, 2010 at 9:57 am
Neither Thom nor I have parents that were in any position to help with the wedding. So we did what we could afford. We flew to Las Vegas and got married at the top of the Stratosphere. We also stayed at that hotel. Three days later we came home married and two weeks later we had a catered reception (Mexican food!) at my sister’s house and invited about 50 people. We bought a dvd of the wedding at played it at the reception. We registered at Target and got pretty much everything we needed at the party.
My sister got married the year before me. And while I was a little jealous of her medium sized, fairly fancy wedding, I felt like I had experienced that with her and didn’t need it for myself. Her husband left her three years later and I’m fairly certain if she marries again she will elope.
Carrisa | March 23rd, 2010 at 10:19 am
My hubby and I had a very “low-cost” homemade type of wedding. It still cost us $5,000 and we knew even as we were planning and spending we would have preferred to run away somewhere tropical. Mom-in-law and sis-in-law were completely opposed to that as they could not afford to join us. We have a number of important people (maybe only about 10, but still) who we would have wanted there but who could not have come if we’d gone, so we gave in gracefully and had a local wedding instead. Our ten yr anniversary has passed us, but sometime I still want that tropical wedding experience in the form of a vow renewal!
Laurie | March 23rd, 2010 at 10:28 am
We wanted to elope but as soon as we got engaged my Mom gave me a lecture about how much eloping would hurt her feelings. It was ridiculous. We ended up having the wedding - and it was a lot of fun - but I wish that we had just gone somewhere sunny with a group of close friends and family.
hillary | March 23rd, 2010 at 11:25 am
A friend who had the family who expected the traditional banquet hall, had the ceremony where they wanted with a few friends and closest family (moms/dads/siblings) and then did the big reception in the banquet hall with the 300 guests a couple months later and showed the wedding video.
They still probably spent a couple thousand, but it wasn’t ten-thousand of the original quotes with limos & flowers for church aisles etc.
Mich | March 23rd, 2010 at 11:40 am
I will either elope or have a super small (destination or family only) wedding. My mother even asked me if I’d elope (after my brother got married). I told her no problem. I’m not interested in planning a wedding and neither is my Mom. I’d rather spend my money on the honeymoon or a new house.
I have a friend who is getting married in May and I told her she was my hero! She is having a small wedding ceremony for her family and then having a picnic style BBQ at her parents house. I told her she was having my dream wedding.
K | March 23rd, 2010 at 11:59 am
I’m torn on this but I think I could easily elope then have a big party when we got back. I know I’d get a lot of shit for it from my mom.
sizzle | March 23rd, 2010 at 12:35 pm
We considered a destination wedding (a pure elopement without any family present wasn’t really something we were interested in), but in the end it seemed important to us to have our priests marry us in the church where we met, witnessed by all the family and friends who wanted to join us in the town we lived in at that point.
We didn’t have to cut every corner — we consciously saved more money to pay for the wedding so that it wasn’t as much work for us — and given that, I’m extremely grateful for the awesome day, surrounded by all the awesome people my husband and I have been priveleged to have in our lives over the years.
Emily | March 23rd, 2010 at 4:30 pm
I have always been a “less is more” person, and my thoughts about my own potential wedding were no exception. But when I was a teen, my mom had mentioned how she would love to have my wedding at her house, with me coming down the oak staircase in my wedding gown, etc., etc. So I felt that since I was her oldest daughter, I should at least let her weigh in on the decision re what kind of wedding to have. Conveniently, though, I never married. My kid sister eventually filled my mom’s need to marry off a daughter, so I guess I am off the hook. At this point, I think it’s safe to say I can elope in peace, if it ever comes to that.
SKL | March 23rd, 2010 at 8:56 pm
Our wedding day was one of the best days of our lives and we planned and paid for the whole shindig (of about 120) ourselves with a little help from our family (they mostly helped make all the food). The beef for the lasagna was a wedding gift from my cowboy brother in law.
We had an absolute blast and our only regrets were that we didn’t listen to our parents a bit more regarding who we should invite (since we were paying for it ourselves that was our excuse to not take their advice). We invited a bunch of friends we never see now instead of a bunch of cousins we see more often but felt like we didn’t know as well.
My only other regret was my bad updo. Boo. Everything else was fabulous, memorable…and we made all our money back and then some with all those gifts!!! I highly recommend the at home wedding (and the near home honeymoon too actually…save that far away exotic trip for when well, you don’t find your mate quite so um… exotic?)
Ruth | March 23rd, 2010 at 10:04 pm
We were 6 months into planning a big wedding when we decided to run off to Jamaica and elope. Best decision I ever made.
Tina | March 24th, 2010 at 5:56 am
I love the idea of eloping if I were ever to get married, but I can’t handle the heat, so that rules out almost everywhere! Other than that, it would be tiny, in Sam’s parents backyard, or my mom’s backyard. I’m not a big fan of stressful, late, intricate parties!
Meg | March 24th, 2010 at 7:02 pm
If I ever marry, I know I’ll want to do it in the church because that is important to me.
However, a big party isn’t! I’ll take a cue from several friends; cake/puch & light apps for the whole crowd at the church.
Some have added a dinner just for the bridal party or just for bridal party & out of towners, something like that.
Mich | March 25th, 2010 at 10:22 am