Member Blogs

Write a blog post

How far do we go to make our child happy?

Posted 26th January 2010 by oceans mom, tagged kids, tantrums, borthday

8 comments  |  Leave a comment  |  Report

I just went to a birthday party where a 2.5 yr old threw a tantrum because he did not get to blow out the candles (it wasn't his birthday). Instead of the mother explaining to him that it was not his birthday and moving on, the mother asked for the host (mother of the birthday boy) light another candle for her son to blow out. This upset the birthday boy but they did it anyway. For some reason, this entire scenario bothered me. If the child had been 1 or 1.5 years old, it would not bother me but the kid was 2.5 for Gods sake and the mother should have at the very least taken a minute to try to explain this to him. I think that it was rude to ask the mother of the birthday boy to then relight the candles so she could indulge her son in his demands. This is just me.





8 comments so far...

  • I totally agree that the mother is indulging her child and sending the wrong message. The terrible twos as it has been called is a time to teach children and set limits. The children crave attention and need to feel loved and accepted. However, in this instance I believe the mother is teaching the child the exact opposite of what the child needs to begin to understand. We need to teach our young ones right from wrong and clearly throwing a temper tantrum to get his/her way is never acceptable.

    Flag as inappropriate Posted by irun2day on 26th July 2011

  • My boyfriend's ex would buy presents for all 3 girls whenever it was one of their birthdays so the others would not feel left out. He told me he always thought this was ridiculous but he felt powerless to change it. After we moved in together I asked him how he would raise his kids if he called all the shots. He listed tons of things he would not allow that he felt were contributing to their spoiled brat attitudes. So I informed him that he was running the show at our house and he could raise his daughters not to be spoiled and I would back him up no matter what.

    His 3 girls are no longer nasty spoiled brats and they only live with us on weekends. Values and good behavior comes from the parents.

    If I was the mother of the birthday boy at that party I would've told that kid to stop being rude or leave. Why are moms so afraid to speak up when they see somebody else's kid acting up? If that mother is one of those entitled types that will probably cost you a friendship but do you really want your kids hanging around a nasty brat like that?

    Flag as inappropriate Posted by Monica Neave on 15th May 2011

  • Oh my goodness! Working retail at Christmas, I cannot tell you how many times I saw parents give in to children throwing tantrums. And all I could think was, "You're making a huge mistake. Your kids totally know how to play you." Situations like that teach the kids exactly how far they need to go to get their way--and too often it isn't very far at all. I think it's a shame that so many parents have trouble setting boundaries for their kids. I feel that it's our job to guide them and give them coping skills, not to be their best buddies. Even if you're not your young child's favorite person at a given moment, you'll still be his or her favorite person most of the rest of the time!

    Flag as inappropriate Posted by jengray on 3rd January 2011

  • wow, imagine the rod that mother is making for her back!!!!
    I'm 100% with all the parents who would have said "build a bridge and get over it or we leave right now!!". I have three kids, 8, 4 and 2, there's no lack of jealousy at certain times, but you have to teach kids that sometimes they aren't the centre of attention. I am oh soooo sick of the parents who are bringing up "entitled" kids with no sense of social boundaries or how to win and lose with respect.
    Bring back the days when political correctness was unheard of because I'm over the obnoxious generation!!

    Flag as inappropriate Posted by Kaybeejaenq on 23rd February 2010

  • I agree with you 100%. Children need to learn that they will be disappointed, upset, etc. sometimes and that that's ok. I think the best thing to do is to acknowledge their child's frustration , provide a short explanation, and then try to distract him/her with something else.

    Flag as inappropriate Posted by Amr on 18th February 2010

  • Wow - I'm thankful that I've never seen such a thing. The fun of goody bags is to give the non-birthday kids a little something to take home, but giving him his own candle, even if it upset the birthday boy? Nuh-uh. We would have moved outside or away from the action and had a quick chat along the lines of "do you want to leave?" if answer is no "stop the tantrum, it is [David's] birthday, so he has candles". My child generally was just excited that there was going to be cake and didn't whine about it not being her day. Now that she's older she's remembering things she likes for her own birthday.

    Flag as inappropriate Posted by Mich on 29th January 2010

  • lol..glad I read this twice..I thought you were talking about your son at first. I agree with you...we can not and should not give into all the whims our children have. The mother of the boy was very wrong ( I'd leave him off your son's birthday list for sure) It was the birthday boys day and cake and candle to blow out...it the birthday boy comes to his Birthday...will his mother let him brow out her sons candle on his cake? Doubt it and if she did she more than likely be upset about it. It was rude...hopefully later someone called her on it. Hugs, Eileen and How are you and your doing?

    Flag as inappropriate Posted by eileen b on 27th January 2010

  • I agree with you. Personally, in that situation, I would take my kid away from the festivites until she got over herself. But a lot of people don't approve of my style; letting your kids be disappointed is less and less socially acceptable, unfortunately.

    I have 2 kids who are 3 months apart. Some jealousy is inevitable. I do think they are a little young to just "suck it up," so I make some adjustments, e.g., have something new (but more modest) for the non-birthday girl too. When my 3yo DD1 looked sad about not getting any cards on DD2's birthday, I brought out a few cards from DD1's birthday, and that made her happy. But at someone else's party, my kids are expected to behave or be removed. That's more a matter of the parent's self-discipline than the child's, in my opinion.

    Flag as inappropriate Posted by SKL on 26th January 2010

Have a question?

Check out our popular Q&A area to ask questions and search for answers.

Quick recipes

Check out our favorite quick and easy recipes, perfect for busy moms.

Affordable Luxuries Blog

Check out our daily picks for affordable luxuries for you and your family.

Support small businesses!