Member Blogs

Write a blog post

Boycotting Parenting Books

Posted 25th February 2009 by Stacey S

4 comments  |  Leave a comment  |  Report

I never really expected to read many parenting books. I have great parents who are wonderful role models, but my church has a parenting class during Sunday school so my husband and I decided to try it. The class uses different parenting books to start discussions. I'm in the middle of the 2nd book and I am done. I give up. I am just going to be a bad mom since I don't stay home. Apparently my daughter runs a huge risk of joining a gang because I am not there every second. No, I'm not exaggerating. This was actuall said. If I can't stay home then I can take my daughter to work. Seriously?

Ok, now I know that there are great moms that do each of these. But just because I work outside the home doesn't mean I am a bad mom. I refuse to spend anymore time or money to have someone make me feel bad. My daughter knows she is loved and I will make a huge effort to be there for her whenever she needs me.  Isn't that what it is about?

I'm done people making me feel bad about how I parent. I am a good mom. I know I am. I'm not perfect, but who is? I know that I will struggle to be a good parent and find time but it is important to me and I will do my best.

At least the books made me realize that I don't need to listen to outside people, but I am done now. No more books. And I think I will be a better parent for that.

Leave a comment

4 comments so far...

  • Well, it isn't a problem with my church - although it was a bible based book so maybe that was it. Luckily my church is very accepting, open and even the SAHMs were appalled by the gang reference.

    I am sure there are good books out there. This last one has been great minus the one chapter. What I have found is that I either agree with them or don't. No one has changed my mind. Maybe I will change my mind on that after my daughter gets a little older.

    Flag as inappropriate Posted by Stacey S on 5th March 2009

  • Sounds like this is more a problem of your church culture than parenting books in general. I think there are some good ones, you just have to find them. I really like Love and Logic, and The No Cry Sleep Solution saved my life when my daughter was a baby.

    It's tough to be in the conservative Christian culture and be a working mom. I'm there too. I'm lucky in that the judgement so far has been more implied than outright, but I'm also not taking a parenting class at church. The ASSUMPTION clearly is that "good, Christian moms" don't work outside the home. All of the activities for mothers take place during working hours. People ask my husband what he does for a living, but don't ask me when I am standing right there. Sometimes I just pipe up and say, "I'm a high school teacher." People do a double take. And I LMAO. Why are religious people sometimes so narrow-minded and judgemental and non-religious people more accepting? It's a mystery to me. It SHOULD be the other way around!

    It takes a while to develop a thicker skin and the confidence to know that the decisions you and your husband make are the best ones for your family. I still have my moments of crappy feeling.

    Check out this blog: www.themommyrevolution.com Get through the comments by the few naysayers and revel in the acceptance of other moms who don't "fit the mold." I'll look for you there, Stacey!

    Flag as inappropriate Posted by Mom2Rylie on 3rd March 2009

  • I threw away "Babywise" after realizing that my child was never going to fit the patterns described in the book. My daughter is unique and as a parent I need to follow my instincts to raise her. No author knows my children the way I do.

    Flag as inappropriate Posted by PRMomAZ on 28th February 2009

  • I'm with you. I know I am a good mom because my 2 year old says thank you and you're welcome(we are still working on please) and I noticed today when he comes in from playing, he takes his coat off and makes an attempt to put it neatly on something. I am sure your daughter has some manners that are absent of the other children running amok in the great US of A these days so don't let them beat you up! Focus on the good things your daughter is learning from you and your husband and the books won't seem so bad, some of them can give insight on a problem you are having and solutions you didn't think of but 99% of it is crapola!

    Flag as inappropriate Posted by the upbeat pessimist on 27th February 2009

Have a question?

Check out our popular Q&A area to ask questions and search for answers.

Quick recipes

Check out our favorite quick and easy recipes, perfect for busy moms.

Affordable Luxuries Blog

Check out our daily picks for affordable luxuries for you and your family.

Subscribe to our Weekly Newsletter