Please log into your Work It, Mom! account to ask a question. If you don't have an account, please register by clicking here.
Devil's Advocate

My 10 month old son will not self feed, except with a bottle. I have bought little finger foods, which he throws everywhere but his mouth. I show him over and over but he won't put them in his mouth. He's a great eater other than that as he will eat literally any food that I put in his mouth. And, he will also put anything in his mouth that is not food! Any suggestions?

Asked by oceans mom, 3rd Jul Answer this now »
Bottom Arrow
Showing 9 replies to this question
YEAH OCEANS MOM!! THAT"S GREAT! Sounds like he's getting it. My kids LOVED puffs. I too hate "food" messes but I learned with my second to just say "whatever" and they also sell these food mats to put under the highchair. It does make the clean up easier. My daughter eats like a champion and my son is getting there.
Tonight I made steak, rice and spinach and I couldn't believe what I was seeing but my son ate the steak like crazy but the Spinach I had to mix into the rice.
lentils are so good for them - my daughter loves lentil soup. Also Pastini and peas. He sounds like he is eating great food:)))

Take Care!
I want to second how important it is to sit and eat meals together. Kids want to imitate you, that's how they learn. Also, if he gets a big reaction from you when he throws something (such as you cracking up), it's more entertaining for him to throw it than put it in his mouth:) I know it can be hard, but it's best if he is not the center of attention at mealtime.

Although, from what you've "said", it sounds like your little one is going to catch on pretty quick.

Some moms have commented on picky kids - I highly recommend the book "Child of Mine" by Ellyn Satter. My daughter is 2 1/2 and I have had zero feeding issues with her. She eat's what she's given or she doesn't. I don't make an issue out of it either way (but if she chooses "doesn't" I don't give her something else). I also used the approach outlined in this book when doing pediatric nutrition counseling. Anyone I know that's expecting gets this book as a gift! No need to pull your hair out with a picky eater!

~Lisa
www.eNutritionServices.com
I finally saw him putting a puff in his mouth this weekend. Most of them did not end up in his mouth but at least he was trying. His fingers go to his mouth but the puff will end up in his palm and he can't figure out how to get it form his palm to fingers to mouth. it's pretty funny, actually. He's not a picky eater, though, he just doesn't know how to feed himself. He will eat anythign I put in his mouth except bananas. Actually, even those he will "eat" to make me happy but he stuffs them in his cheeks until they pour out. Everything else though he likes. I usually feed him Lentils, brown rice, tofu, peas, sweet potatoes and anything that I give him off of my plate, literally anything (except bananas!). But now he is finally at least trying to put the puffs in his mouth. I blame us for not letting him touch his food for the longest time because we didn't want a mess. I think that he thinks that if we are letting him touch it, it must not be food or something.
Keep in mind, he's only 10.5 months, so the biggest piece of advice I have is to be patient. For the FIRST YEAR, solid foods are for PRACTICE. Formula should still be a big part of his caloric intake. Nearly all experts agree on this principle. My son started finger foods around 9-10 months (puffs and O's only) and has slowly shown more interest and now feeds himself about 70% of his meals. But at 10-11 months, we were feeding him his real food. Even now at 14 months, he is hit and miss on "using" the spoon. Every child gets there at their own pace.
Are you eating meals with him? For the longest time, we continued to eat our dinner after he went to bed. It was easier than me trying to get dinner on the table by 6:30. We're getting better at the timing (we give him a snack in the car and eat around 7 to achieve family dinner time) and he seems to be picking up on eating because he sees us doing the same thing.
That said, we've found that he's more likely to eat on his own (and more) if we aren't pouring over his every move. Having our own meal to eat helps that too. Just be patient and it will happen. Continue to offer opportunities to feed himself but I would personally not advise withholding food as a punishment for not feeding himself. The less of a reward/punishment you can make food from day one, the better.
Nope, I didn't misunderstand. Actually, I totally agree with Momof2lovelies. As strange as it may sound, he may well be in a power mode and strangely enough, testing YOU as to how much he can get his way. And don't think it can't happen at that young age. They learn very quickly how far they can get. Mom's idea of "you eat what we eat" is totally correct. I'm in firm belief that picky eaters are made, not born. If you don't allow it to happen, then it won't. By NOT cooking 2 different meals, you let them know that they don't make the rules, you do.

Now, obviously in your situation, you're dealing with an infant/toddler. However, the beginnings are there. BTW, my husband absolutely HATED letting our daughter try to feed herself. He hated seeing the speg. sauce all over her, her PALE blonde hair and head, fingers, food tray, etc. But as I told him, she's gotta learn that it goes in the hole marked "Mouth". :-D

He'll learn, but the important thing is for you NOT to give in.

Oh, and btw, my baby 1st cousin was a picky eater (still is, btw). Got to the point that all she'd eat was dried spegaetti and liquid jello. My aunt was afraid she'd also wind up anemic (she was about 8/9 when she was doing this. The doctor finally told her that she was fine and that she WOULD eat when she got hungry enough, just DON'T give in to her. He was right, tho the seeds of pickiness had already been sown. She's healthy/happy at 32.
My son is a terrible eater. I recently found out he is anemic and only 4 yrs old. He was also born with digestive issues so food is a sore spot with me. Getting my son to eat is always a challenge. Up until I found out about the anemia, I would usually allow the basics. Pasta, Chicken Nuggets, baked fries, occassional pizza, corn, fruits and few veggies.
The night I found out about anemia, I said "that's it" he is going to learn to eat what we eat and like it.
That night I made him steamed spinach, quinoa, and chicken. He refused it and said he didn't like the new cous cous(quinoa). He ate a few pieces of the chicken and was still hungry. I said "well you have perfectly good food waiting for you, it's here when you want it and don't ask for ice crea, cookies or anything else". We talked about the new information and his health and what we need to do in terms of food and that mommy would be making one meal for everyone and either everyone eats it or you can make the decision to go to bed hungry.
That night he went to bed hungry...IT KILLED ME but I knew I would work out.
The next night I made organiz cheese burgers. He never ate one before. He resisted at first and then I reminded him of our rules and it was his decision to go to bed hungry. HE ATE THE ENTIRE CHEESE BURGER!!!! I also had him help me make the patties. He put his chef's hat & apron on. We took pictures of us cooking together and everything.
Tonight we went for mexican and he at a rice and bean burrito. Resisted at first and then I gave him the look...he ate it and said "MOM, I really like this!" On the way over to the restaurant, I talked to him about our Mexican adventure and how cool it was that he was going to try something new.

Obviously yours is too young for that but he will come around. As frustrating as that might sound, he could be in power mode. Let him eat a bread stick. Put some peas on his highchair, banana sticks(cut the banana in sticks. Eating your dinner as he eats his is a good way to show him mommy self feeds too. A few tries and he will get it. His curiosity will get the best of him sooner or later.

My daughter didn't really master the self feeding outside of cheerios until 11 to 12 months. I know it can be exhausting. Hang in there. He's still young. A month or two makes a big difference.
He will get there. Leave food on his highchair and he'll come around.

Good Luck!
KC  3rd Jul
My son is 10.5 months and is only now learning to feed himself. He wouldn't do it for the longest time: he would only eat the food that I fed him and not the food which was in his hand. We just had to be very pateint. Daycare providers also have been working with him.
I think you misunderstood the question, although you have a good point about other issues. The problem isn't that he throws things and I pick them up and feed him. I actually don't want to give him food back that's been on the floor and I don't. He's not really understanding the concept that he can put food in his mouth. He'll play with the little puff pieces on his high chair and toss them about. He doesn't seem upset if they disappear or anything. He just doesn't really understand that it's okay to eat it himself or something. At first he used to try to swallow them whole, even though he has some teeth (but, again, only if I give it to him). I put them in my mouth and showed him how to chew or mash it with his gums, and now he has that part down. He just won't put the food in his mouth with his own fingers. It's really weird.
Ever hear of the game "if I throw it down, they'll pick it up and give it back?"

How do you stop that game? You don't give it back.

Oddly enough, even littile ones learn quickly how to manipulate the parents.

Want to break it? Don't give the bottle. Give the food. If they throw it, you don't give it back. If they throw it all, then you don't give it back. Now, before you say, "Oh that's cruel..." Think about it. They're already associating action v. reaction and HOW to get what they want. You've got to fight fire with fire here. If they want the bottle, No. just the food. After a time, they'll finally put 2 and 2 together (in their own way, of course) and realize Mom's not gonna give them a bottle, but the food and I'm hungry, so eat the food and I'm not hungry anymore.

After all, you don't pop a bottle in their mouth every time they cry in the night, now do you? Nope, you let them cry it out and learn to fall back asleep on their own.

Same principle.
Write Your Answer
Please sign in to answer this question. If you don't have a Work It, Mom! account, it takes just a minute to join.
Latest Questions and Answers